Shelter Island Real Estate
Shelter Island
Island Privacy Between Two Forks
Price Range
$1M – $25M+
Zip Code
11964
Character
Private, pastoral, and authentic. An island refuge with deep roots.
Shelter Island offers a pace and sense of seclusion unlike anywhere else in the Hamptons. Accessible only by ferry or private boat, the island is defined by preserved land, quiet coves, and a close-knit community. Waterfront homes, historic cottages, and private compounds appeal to buyers seeking a genuine escape without leaving the East End.
What Makes Shelter Island Special
Protected bays, coves, and private waterfront with exceptional boating
Mashomack Preserve’s thousands of acres of conserved landscape
Historic homes and summer cottages alongside discreet new construction
Walkable Greenport and Sag Harbor access by ferry
Low-density island living with a deeply private character
Beaches
Notable Sales in Shelter Island
$3,500,000
47B South Ferry Road, Shelter Island
Private Sale
BD · BA · SF · AC
Your Shelter Island Specialist
Looking to Buy or Sell in Shelter Island?
As an oceanfront and waterfront specialist at Hedgerow Exclusive Properties, I offer access to on-market and off-market opportunities across Shelter Islandand the entire East End.
Schedule a ConsultationBarry McGovern is a luxury real estate broker and oceanfront & waterfront specialist at Hedgerow Exclusive Properties, the #1 ranked Hamptons firm by WSJ/RealTrends with nearly $2 billion in transactions. Specializing in Shelter Island oceanfront estates, waterfront homes, off-market properties, and luxury real estate. Serving Shelter Island, Southampton, Bridgehampton, Sag Harbor, Sagaponack, East Hampton, Amagansett, Montauk, and Shelter Island.